Big Olaf Creamery
Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts
Big Olaf has been at the heart of Siesta Key Village since it opened its doors in 1982. Big Olaf offers over 40 flavors of ice cream, milkshakes, soft serve, sundaes, alpines, floats and smoothies as well as freshly made waffle cones and fudge made in store. While Siesta Key was the site of the original creamery because of growth the creamery is now located in Sarasota’s Amish village of Pinecraft where the ice cream is made by local Amish craftsmen and brought out fresh daily. The homemade ice cream is made using fresh 14% butterfat milk and fresh ingredients giving it the ultra-creamy flavor and texture it’s known for. Though Big Olaf often has long lines they move quickly and it’s always worth the wait. Whether you’re a local or on vacation Big Olaf of Siesta Key is absolutely a must do when you’re in the village.