Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts All Locations... Mainland Sarasota CountySiesta Key VillageSouth Bridge Gateway go Results Found: 5 Button group with nested dropdown Big Olaf Creamery 5208 Ocean Boulevard Siesta Key FL 34242 (941) 349-9392 Abel's Ice Cream 1886 Stickney Point Road Sarasota FL 34231 (941) 921-5700 Made in Rome Organic Gelato Made in Rome Organic Gelato 5204 Ocean Boulevard Siesta Key FL 34242 (941) 960-5344 Kona Ice Sarasota Kona Ice Sarasota 6301 Porter Road, Suite 2 Sarasota FL 34240 (941) 685-2881 Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream 219 Avenida Madera Siesta Key FL 34242 (941) 349-4062